Monday, 12 August 2024

Dancing on Her Grave: The Usage of Marie Antoinette in Modernity

Few people has been subjected to such intense public anger and dehumanization as Marie Antoinette - even after her death. The story of her mistreatment and eventual death is well-known but the ire of public imagination has not subsided over the years. The revolutionary (and pre-revolutionary) propaganda was immensely successful and has largely shaped the way we still perceive the ill-fated queen. 


However, whereas Marie Antoinette's image is used on a variety of consumer products such as hair brushes, perfumes and even cakes, the darker side is the continual usage of her tragic demise. As late as July 2024, the Paris Olympics used graphic imagery of a beheaded Marie Antoinette holding her own head (singing for good measure) in her arms, for the opening ceremony. To make matters even more macabre, the imagery was depicted from the windows of the Conciergerie - the prison in which she spent her last days.


Marie Antoinette, as depicted during the opening
ceremony of the Olympics, 2024


While the French Revolution is obviously of immense importance to both French history and modern French society, it is revolting to see how the mutilated and murdered body of a long-dead and even longer vilified woman is still used as a prop for entertainment. The planners could easily have represented the fall of the monarchy in other ways - even the tumultuous times of the Terror could have been presented. Such a representation would have been entirely in line with the other parts of the opening ceremony which relied heavily on French history - as it should, given the locale of the ceremony. 

Alas, the only person to have her stand-in corpse utilized in this graphic manner was Marie Antoinette. One might wonder why there was no headless Louis XVI peeking out from the windows, especially considering that he not only held the actual political power but was the only one of the two who represented the hated Bourbon-dynasty. The two could have been joined by a slightly shorter-than-life Robespierre.

Instead, Marie Antoinette remained the sole symbol of the fall of the French monarchy - she remain the scapegoat of an entire outdated system which had become a hallmark of inequality and exploitation, despite having had no direct political power nor having even been born into the reigning dynasty. 


The tradition of using Marie Antoinette for commercial gains is nothing new. Countless Halloween-costumes allow trick-and-treaters to don bloodied court dresses for a night out. Some even offer tricks to "decapitate yourself" a la Marie Antoinette or include necklaces to make it seem as if the head has been reattached. For those who wish to have a more lasting souvenir, it is possible to purchase posters - naturally, with the queen sans tête.


In an Avantgarde photo exhibition by Erwin Olaf from 2000, the artist took inspiration from royal tragedies. His exhibition "Royal Blood" contained numerous references to very real tragedies - a Jackie Kennedy, first pristine in white with her signature hat, then splattered with (her husband's) blood, a very Princess Diana-looking model with a deep cut into her arm - and Marie Antoinette, holding her own head, yet again.


Erwin Olaf's Marie Antoinette


In fairness to Olaf, he is far from the only one who saw fit to use the ci-devant queen's decapitated head as a prop. The Long Island City's Sculpture Centre once exhibited a "Banquet of the Beheaded" with Marie Antoinette's (and others') heads served on actual platters. 


The Banquet of the Beheaded - Marie Antoinette
From the Banquet of the Beheaded


One of the more disturbing aspects of the exploitation of her death has been by toy makers. The company Archie McPhee & Co has carried several items which can be categorised as downright disrespectful. For one, there was the lollypop shaped as the head of the beheaded queen, ripe for consumption. Another addition was the action figure which might seem innocent enough with its accompanying court gown/peasant gown accessories. One might wonder why the company felt the need to install a clicker which makes the doll's head fly off its shoulders.

Marie-Antoinette action figure and Call for other objets d'art of  revolutionary culture – A Revolution in Fiction
Toy by Archie McPhee & Co


One enthusiastic buyer of the toy amusedly commented: "My friends, students, and family have so enjoyed playing with our Marie-Antoinette that her plastic head socket has gotten a bit out of joint. Thus my question: how, oh how, will I ever get the queen’s head back on her shoulders?!"

Even the small-business owners on Etsy have gotten in on the fun. It is possible to purchase dolls of both Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI with their heads cut off and a clear view of their severed throats. Another seller outright sells the queen's decapitated head - replica, naturally, but complete with a bloody neckline and eyes rolling back. The latter has already been sold and is thus adorning someone's home or perhaps served as a Halloween prop.


Doll head from Etsy


There appear to be no end to the creativity connected with producing objects that focus on Marie Antoinette's decapitation. If the toy and lollipop were not enough, one could always try the salt and pepper shaker from acornonline.com. Naturally, the head comes off, so the customer can fill the shaker. And the sales description? "A magnet attaches Marie Antoinette's head to her shoulders until the contents — salt and pepper — are required. Then it's off with Her Majesty's head" 



It is tempting to wonder what it is, exactly, about the very beheading that keeps people amused. All the usages of the queen mentioned in this post have been focused on the removal of her head, whether through images or by allowing the customer to wring off the head themselves. Perhaps the idea of beheading her again and again simply have an irresistible appeal? A perpetual punishment?


While the depiction of the bad side of royalty has always been popular  - and still is - there is a marked difference between plastering the profile of a coiffured Marie Antoinette on a pastel-colored umbrella and using the decapitated, blood-dripping head of the queen for dramatic or even amusing effect. 

When dealing with historical figures, it is all too easy to forget that they were actual people once. While Marie Antoinette herself certainly had flaws, it is hard to argue that she still - 231 years after her death - merit having her gruesome end (body and head) utilized in this manner.

Thursday, 16 May 2024

The King's Floral Favourite: Orange Trees of Louis XIV

Whereas Marie Antoinette's love of flowers was - and still is - widely known, she was not the only monarch at Versailles with a taste for floras. A century before the ill-fated queen arrived in France, her kinsman, Louis XIV, was proudly displaying his own taste for plants. In the Sun King's case, it was not the delicate violets or roses favoured by Marie Antoinette but rather the exotic orange blossoms.

The king loved the exquisite scent of orange blossoms as well as its prestige - after all, it is a plant that requires a certain degree of both warmth and care to grow. It has also been suggested that the king was attracted to the symbolism of the fruit - looking suspiciously like a sun, it was the ideal symbol for the Sun King. Furthermore, they were very expensive, thus aptly showcasing the king's wealth. For that reason, it is hardly a surprise that the king commissioned Le Vau to complete the impressive Orangery at Versailles. The king placed his order with La Vau as early as 1664 but twenty years later, he hired Mansart to considerably expand the building (at a further cost of over 1.5 million livres). Located immediately below the palace - its roof making up the very foundation of the parterres - the Orangery was the home of several southern additions: lemon trees, olives, dates, oleander - and orange trees. The building itself is impressive - vaulted galleries packed with greenery and large windows to let in the precious sunlight.

The king's initial reaction to his Orangery is recorded by the marquis de Dangeau. On 14 November 1685, "the king walked in the orangery at Versailles which he found very magnificent". 


Figure 1. « Jardiniers à l’œuvre dans l’orangerie de Versailles », dans J.-B. de La Quintinie, Instruction pour les jardins fruitiers et potagers, Paris, C. Barbin, 1690
Gardeners at work at the Orangery of Versailles
 during Louis XIV

The king's gardener imported the precious trees from all over southern Europe but favoured the Portuguese, Spanish and Italian ones. Yet, he did not limit himself to those regions - seeds were brought in from as far away as Santa Domingo and Algeria. The Portuguese were often imported from as far afield as China which sent their cost skyrocketing. Even those amongst his courtiers who had their own trees were approached with an offer of sale. One enterprising lady - the Duchesse de La Ferté - agreed to sell her twenty fully grown orange trees to the king for 2.200 livres. In comparison, the wages of Louis XIV's first gardener - Laurent Trumel - was 3.000 livres per year. Yet, even she sold her trees comparatively cheaply. The Duchesse de Verneuil sold 52 orange trees for 10.083 livres while one another receipt shows that the sourcing of orange trees "from various environs" cost the king another 38.175 livres.

It certainly helped that when Louis confiscated the estate of Nicolas Fouquet, his former superintendent of finance was said to have had up to a 1.000 orange trees - almost certainly a massive exaggeration, but those he did have were duly transferred to the king.

There appears to have been something almost frantic about the king's desire to gather as many trees as possible. For instance, he did not wait until summer for the precious cargo to be transported but had them delivered throughout the year, including in the depths of winter. Unfortunately, this meant that a considerable amount were dead on arrival. The king also ordered his existing stock of orange trees moved from his various other residences to fill the vaults of the Orangery. The intensive gathering resulted in Louis XIV having the largest collection of orange trees in Europe.

During the winter and colder periods, the trees were moved into the warmth and safety of the Orangery where they would be sheltered from the wind and rain. However, during the summer they were rolled out in all their glory - that was also the case when the king had guests to impress. For instance, the king had his collection on full display when the Siamese ambassador and his entourage visited France in 1686.



Interior of the Orangery


Part of the prestige also consisted in keeping the orange trees alive - all year round. Upon the completion of the Orangery, 12.000 seedlings were transferred to the new establishment and the royal gardener was tasked with keeping them blooming on rotation. As a result, the king could enjoy his orange trees even during winter. The orange trees in the royal apartments were replaced in intervals of 15 days - ensuring that they would seemingly never wither. Initially, they were planted in solid silver pots, but the ongoing wars eventually made it necessary to melt down such luxuries. 

To aid in his efforts, the king's gardener (La Quintinie) sought the expert advice of Henri Dupuis who specialised in citrus fruits. Dupuis would also be asked to supply more orange trees for the king's insatiable garden. It apparently worked for La Quintinie managed to invent his own variant of rooting which proved particularly successful. His mixture consisted of cow dung, powdered night soil (whatever that means), pigeon droppings, sheep manure, sand from Fontainebleau, grape marc and composted sod. 

Having thus steeped the trees in three different types of excrement, La Quintinie turned his attention to how to keep the trees alive for longer. He discovered that by storing the young trees in planters made of oak with hatch walls (another invention of his own), he could then transfer them to larger urns. This served to keep the trees alive for decades and is a technique even used today.

It was a massive undertaking to keep the trees alive. By their very nature, orange trees are intended for a warm climate - and Paris in the 17th century was far from that. As it happens, the world was in the midst of a so-called "mini ice-age" which meant considerably lower temperatures than today - and made the work of the king's gardener all the more difficult.


undefined
The Orangery, 1690

As could be expected, even such a personal preference could be turned into a sign of favour. Louis XIV took to bestowing orange trees on favourite courtiers or as rewards for special deeds. When Madame de Montespan was at the height of her favour, Louis made sure that her private estate of Clagny was suitably equipped. In 1675 alone, Colbert paid a staggering 23.000 livres solely for orange trees for Clagny. The king even demanded that the most beautiful ones were taken to her ... "to please me" as he gallantly put it. While Madame de Montespan certainly enjoyed her share of the favour, there was another (albeit unintended) beneficent to the king's chosen trees: his wife.

Marie Thérèse had grown up in the sunlight of Spain and thus was well-acquainted with the scents and sights of orange trees from her childhood. Even though the king sent the best trees to his mistress, one might hope that his wife got her share too.


The scent itself was a massive part of Louis' attraction to this particular type of citrus. As a young man he had reveled in the strong, heady scents of his time but as he grew older, he became increasingly sensitive to them. Rather than the strong tuberose, he now favoured orange blossom.

The king's table was also benefited from the produce of the king's favoured tree. Oranges were duly incorporated into the king's meals, including marmalades, compots and tarts. During the weekly appartements, oranges were amongst the refreshments served in the Salon of Venus. It should be said that the king was far from the only one at court who enjoyed a good orange tree. The prince de Condé had a private collection which amounted to 215 trees in 1709 but even that paled in comparison to the 246 owned by the Duchesse d'Aiguillon. Meanwhile the Louvois-family could boast a collected number of 533.


There can be little doubt that the king was genuinely interested in the well-fare of his beloved trees. Even while campaigning in Franche-Comté, he inquired of Colbert how his trees were doing: "Tell me what the orange trees look like". While at Huy in 1675, he also ordered his trusted Colbert to continue furnishing La Montespan with more trees. Apparently, a fresh shipment had only recently arrived and the king was anxious to see them thrive. And thrive they did - today, eight of the king's own orange trees are still standing in his Orangery at Versailles.

Wednesday, 8 May 2024

Catherine-Charlotte de Gramont, Duchesse de Boufflers

Catherine-Charlotte de Gramont was born in 1669 (some sources say 1670) but the exact date is uncertain. She was the eldest daughter of the Duc de Gramont which automatically put her on the path to an excellent marriage. Her childhood was likely spent away from court and she does not appear in public records until 1693. At the age of 24 (or 23) she was married off to the 49-year old Louis-François de Boufflers.

The same year as her marriage, Catherine-Charlotte suddenly fell seriously ill. She had contracted smallpox before the wedding but survived and made it down the aisle. Despite having contracted a disease notorious for leaving its victims scarred, Catherine-Charlotte was still described as being beautiful and "well-made" - her portrait shows her dark, almost black, hair and deep dark eyes. The marriage contract was signed by the king himself and she received a considerable dowry of 400.000 livres, 200.000 livres worth of silver and 200.000 livres worth of land.


Catherine-Charlotte



Her new husband was a traditional courtier soldier - he held the rank of Maréchal de France by the time of their marriage which automatically made Catherine-Charlotte the Maréchale de Boufflers. She was officially received at court by Louis XIV and Madame de Maintenon. The king quickly rewarded his numerous militaristic exploits (including five separate wars and at least 12 battles) by elevating him to a dukedom. It should not be disregarded that Catherine-Charlotte's own connections made the elevation more palatable - after all, as the daughter of a duke, it was not unusual for her family to lend their support to her husband's elevation.

Catherine-Charlotte quickly fell pregnant and spent the next ten years given birth to a total of eight children. Sadly, most died in childhood:

  • 1694: Louise-Antoinette - became Marquise de Remiencourt
  • 1695: Antoinette-Hippolyte - became a nun and died at 22
  • 1696: Antoine-Charles - died at 15 from smallpox
  • 1698: Charlotte-Julie - also became a nun
  • 1700: Louis-François - died at age 6
  • 1702: Catherine-Berthe - moved to Spain and became Duchesse de Pepoli as well as Dame d'Honneur to the Spanish queen
  • 1704: Marie-Joséphine - became Duchesse d'Alincourt and dame de palais to Marie Leszczynska
  • 1706: Joseph-Marie - inherited the dukedom of Boufflers

Just five years later, Catherine-Charlotte found herself a widow when her husband died in 1711. As can be seen above, her children were scattered and five of them she would not have seen again.

She never remarried nor did she particularly need to. She was a duchess, a respectable mother of a new duke and widely respected for her character. There was only one thing that might have obliged her to remarry: money. Despite having had a large fortune, her husband had spent the majority of it, primarily as expenses for his military career. As a result, the king offered him a pension of 12.000 livres per year. Apparently, he had had a taste for doing his duty in splendour with even the Duc de Saint-Simon acknowledging his (expensive) tastes. Amongst others, he kept an open table which was furnished with countless dishes free for everyone. Such things cost money - a lot of money.


undefined
Her husband, Louis-François

During Louis XIV's reign, Catherine-Charlotte enjoyed the double fortune of being admired herself for her character but also being married to a man who had the king's favour. In 1701 she had even followed her husband to Brussels where her husband held military command. She was received with considerable honour. 

As it happens, Catherine-Charlotte was a woman of strong morals which likely helped her secure the position of Premiere Dame d'Honneur to the new queen, Marie Leszczynska, in 1725. Truly, Catherine-Charlotte was ideal for the role. Her reputation was spotless - no rumours of affairs or intrigues - and her rank made her suitable. Furthermore, she was now in her mid-fifties and had experience running her own household.

Yet, if she thought her middle-age would shield her from scandal, she was wrong. It was not her own conduct which brought her embarrassment but rather that of her son. Joseph-Marie was amongst the six gentlemen who were publicly exiled from court due to "indecent behaviour" - a byword for homosexuality in the day. As mentioned, her own behaviour was without scandal. She was nicknamed "Madame Pataclin" which was the name of the head of the Hôtel de Pitié-Salpêtrière - a home for women being punished for prostitution. The reason? She was the head of the queen's household and the king had made it a habit of finding his mistresses there.


Catherine-Charlotte managed the queen's household for a decade before finally resigning. During her tenure, she aided in having her daughter-in-law, Madeleine Angélique de Neufville, placed as dame de Palais to the queen. She had lived at Versailles during her time as Premier Dame - a privilege closely connected with her position. However, once she resigned, she also moved away from court and seemingly voluntarily. The Duc de Luynes reported that in 1737, she had been to court several times but never slept there, even despite the king's attempts at scheduling audiences late, so she would not have to travel back to her own abode. Interestingly, Luynes - one of Marie Leszczynska's closest friends - remarked that the queen received Catherine-Charlotte with politeness but coldly. Perhaps something had happened between them?

A clue is found in other remarks of Luynes' over the years. According to the duke, Marie Leszczynska had once remarked that the Maréchale de Boufflers had prevented those with entrées from entering the queen's apartments between 17.00-19.00 which meant that the queen was effectually trapped with her ladies in her own apartments. Not only does this show how little power the queen had over her own daily life but would also explain the rather frosty reception. The wording suggests a clash of wills between the two women. According to Luynes, the queen had said that Catherine-Charlotte had "fantasized" about thus restricting the queen - the choice of word seems to indicate that the queen clearly opposed the move.


By now, Catherine-Charlotte was nearing her 70th birthday and her health was failing. She died on 25 January 1739, at the age of 69.

Monday, 29 April 2024

Impot du Sang: The Price of Nobility

Military service was the traditional avenue of service for aristocratic men - the older branches of the French aristocracy particularly distinguished themselves from the newer, bourgeoisie nobility whose very nobility had been bestowed on them due to bureaucratic services. Those families who had earned their nobility by military service was known as the noblesse d'épée (nobility of the sword) whereas the newer ones were referred to as the noblesse de robe (nobility of the robe). 


Naturally, warfare included an obvious risk of injury or death - not to mention the financial loss incurred by the families who had to pay for their own equipment, transportation, food etc. during campaign. During the reigns of Louis XIV, Louis XV and Louis XVI, France was involved in 27 conflicts. These varied from minor skirmishes with foreign countries to full-blown wars such as the Thirty Years' War or the War of the Austrian Succession.


The losses of three families are further explored in this post: Montmorency, Choiseul and Rochechouart. These families all suffered particularly from the French conflicts. In the period of 1621 - 1762, the Choiseul family lost 24 (!) men to warfare while another 4 were injured. Meanwhile, Montmorency (1632 - 1760) experienced 12 fatalities and 13 injuries while the house of Rochechouart (1621-1746) was reduced by 11 men with a further 6 suffering severe injuries.


Rather morbid, this duty had been referred to as the "impot du sang" - the blood tax.


Montmorency 

Georges de Montmorency, Vicomte de Roullers
Killed at the siege of Arras, 1640

Guy de Montmorency-Laval-Bois-Dauphin (unknown first-name)
This gentleman was wounded at the siege of Mardick (13 August 1646) but survived. However, he was relocated to Dunkirk where he was wounded again; this second injury proved to be fatal and he died that same year.

François-Ignace de Montmorency, Comte d'Esterre 
Served as a cavalry captain when he was killed at the battle of Lens in 1684

Gilles de Montmorency-Laval, Chevalier de Bois-Dauphin
Killed during a skirmish in the outskirts of Stenay, 1650

Jacques de Montmorency-Laval, Marquis de Bois-Dauphin
Killed at the siege of Candie, August 1669

Charles de Montmorency-Laval, Marquis de Bois-Dauphin (likely the successor of the man above)
Killed during the defense of Woerden, 1672, when the dutch made sortie against the French 

Charles de Montmorency
Fatally wounded at the battle of Maastricht in 1673

X de Montmorency 
Had his thigh broken by a musket while serving at Mayence, 1689

Henri de Montmorency
Killed at Mayence, 1689, at the age of 18

X de Montmorency
Was also present at Mayence where he was killed in September 1689

Henri-François de Montmorency, Duc de Luxembourg
Maréchal de France and captain of the king's bodyguards, he was wounded at the battle of Rethel in 1650, at the siege of Valenciennes and again - a wound to his hand - in 1678

Léon de Montmorency, Marquis de Fosseuse
Killed at the battle of Marsaille in 1693

X de Montmorency, Comte d'Esterre 
Wounded in 1700 after which he returned to service. He received a fresh wound to the throat which he somehow survived and was made Knight of the Golden Fleece for his troubles.

Charles de Montmorency, Prince de Robecque
Wounded at Landau in 1703

X de Montmorency, Chevalier de Luxembourg
Wounded on 18 October 1705 near Serès

Claude-Roland de Montmorency, Comte de Laval
Wounded by a cannon ball before Nice in December 1705

François de Montmorency, Marquis de Montmorency
Knight of the Saint-Louis, François was wounded in the neck on 18 June 1712 while giving chase to enemy troops

François de Montmorency-Laval
Shot in the jaw at the siege of Fribourg on 13 October 1712 which killed him

Paul-Sigismond de Montmorency, Duc de Châtillon
Another Knight of the Saint-Louis, Paul-Sigismond was also a brigadier of the king's army when he was seriously wounded in the leg at Nerwinde in 1692 - he survived and lived until 1731.

Charles-François-Frédéric de Montmorency-Luxembourg, Duc de Piney-Luxembourg
Undoubtedly one of the most titled persons on this list, he was also duke of Beaufort-Montmorency and prince of both Tingry and d'Aigremont. He was likewise wounded at Nerwinde in 1693.

X de Montmorency de Fosseux
Knight of Malta and simply reported as having "died in the king's service"

Charles-Auguste de Montmorency, Prince de Robecque
Grandee of Spain, Charles-Auguste was wounded by a musket shot in the arm at Chiari in 1701, received another wound in 1705 before being finally "lightly" wounded in the neck in 1709.

Christian-Louis de Montmorency-Luxembourg, Prince de Tingry
Knight of Saint-Louis and Maréchal de France, he was wounded when battling the Habsburg forces in 1705 at Mantes

X de Montmorency-Laval, Marquis de Laval
Wounded at Raucoux in 1746

Joseph-Pierre de Montmorency, Comte d'Olonne 
Head of Schomberg's regiment, he was wounded on 11 August 1760 at Ober-Istingen



Choiseul


Charles de Choiseul, Marquis de Praslin
Charles was a Maréchal de France who had participated in 53 sieges and 27 battles - clearly a career soldier, he had sustained 22 battle wounds over his career.

Henri-Louis de Choiseul, Comte de Sorcy
Lieutenant-general and colonel of a regiment bearing his own name, Henri-Louis was seriously injured at Denain in 1742
 
Marc-Gabriel-Florent-Christophe de Choiseul-Beaupré
Colonel of the Navarre Regiment, he was wounded by a gunshot at the battle of Laufeldt in 1747

Claude-Antoine-Cleriadus de Choiseul-Beaupré
Lieutenant-general and a knight of Saint-Louis was wounded by two strikes by a saber in 1762 - he survived but was later guillotined in 1792


undefined
César I - founder of the
ducal, and martial, house
of Choiseul

Maximilien de Choiseul
Serving as a cornet in the king's cavalry, Maximilien was killed in the siege of Spire in 1644

Chrétien de Choiseul
Brother of Maximilien, he was killed while on campaign in Germany

Giles de Choiseul, Vicomte d'Hostel (also referred to as the Comte d'Hostel)
A Maréchal de Camp, Giles was also a lieutenant-colonel when he was killed in the siege of Saint-Ya in 1644.

Antoine de Choiseul-Beaupré, Seigneur d'Aillecourt
A major in the Duc d'Orléans' cavalry regiment, he was fatally wounded in the battle of Lens (1648). He was taken as a prisoner of war and would succumb to his wounds while in captivity.

César de Choiseul
Knight of Malta who died at the battle of Cremone in 1648. He was 20 years old at the battle - a bittersweet fact is that his father (the Duc de Choiseul) would go on to win that particular battle.

Charles de Choiseul, Comte de Plessis  
Brother of César, Charles was a Maréchal de Camp when he died at the battle of Rethel in 1650

X de Choiseul
His death was announced in the Mercure Gallante, but unfortunately, his first-name is not clearly recorded.  He was the brother of César and Charles - however, he might have been an illegitimate brother. He died at the siege of Ast in 1644.

Alexandre de Choiseul, Comte de Plessis-Praslin
Yet another brother of César and Charles, Alexandre was killed at 38 by a cannon ball at the taking of Arnheim, 1672. He had initially been accepted into the Church but left the clergy to join the army.

Charles de Choiseul
Killed at the battle of Cassel in 1677

François de Choiseul
Killed at the siege of Candie, 1668

Adrien de Choiseul, Seigneur de Vauteau
Killed at the siege of Condé 

Jean-Baptiste-Gaston de Choiseul, Comte d'Hostel and Marquis de Praslin
He was another career soldier who had achieved the rank of lieutenant-general who had been seriously injured at the siege of Iprès in 1678. He later had his hand broken by a bullet during the battle of Cassano (1705) - he continued fighting until he was shot through the torso. He was taken to the ducal palace of Milan where he died after several hours of agony.

Claude-Bernard de Choiseul
Killed in Germany, 1679

Pierre de Choiseul
Unlike his relatives, Pierre joined the navy where he was killed during the bombardment of Algiers in 1683.

César-Auguste II de Choiseul, Duc de de Choiseul
Serving as Premier Gentilhomme of the Duc d'Orléans, the duke was mortally wounded when he led the siege of Luxembourg in 1684 - a bomb (likely a cannon ball) exploded right near him. He was not yet 20 years old.

François-Joseph de Choiseul
Knight of Malta who was killed at the Battle of Nerwinde of 1693

Cleriadus de Choiseul, Marquis de Lanques
Died at the head of his regiment in the 1690's

X de Choiseul
Another Knight of Malta and another man whose name does not appear clearly. He was killed at Spire, 1703.

Charles de Choiseul, Marquis de Meuze
Also killed at Spire

François-Joseph de Choiseul, Comte de Choiseul and Baron de Beaupré
Killed during a naval battle in 1711

François de Choiseul-Ambouville 
Served as an ensign in the navy when he was killed at Algiers on 27 June 1683

Comte de de Choiseul-Beaupré
Captain of his vessel, he was killed in action on 18 May 1711

François-Louis de Choiseul-Meuze
Colonel of the Regiment of the Dauphin, he was killed at Anvers on 31 May 1746


As can be seen, the house of Choiseul paid heavily for their military duty towards the king. Few - if any - noble family lost as many men during such a relatively short period. As a further example, the head of the house - César Auguste III - participated in nine conflicts over the span of 23 years. In the 1670's, especially, César Auguste was continuously absent as he was at war in 1672, 1674, 1675, 1677 and 1678. During these years, he travelled to various fronts, including in the Netherlands and Belgium. In total, he spent 32 years in active service.

Such service was an ideal opportunity for the king to reward obvious fidelity. To be sure, Louis XIV fully appreciated this concept and did not fail on his part. César Auguste went from colonel of an infantry regiment to maréchal de France (and lieutenant-general), made First Gentleman of the Bedchamber to the Duc d'Orléans and was made a Knight of the Saint-Esprit.

Particularly the family of Charles de Choiseul and Marie de Porcherot saw more than their fair share of the "impot du sang" - they had eight children of which four sons died in war: Charles, François, Pierre and Claude-Bernard.

The Battle of Spire, 1703, which killed off 
numerous men from the Choiseul-family


Rochechouart

Guy de Rochechouart, Seigneur de Châtillon-de-Roy
Killed at the siege of Saint-Jean d'Angely in 1621

Jean-Louis de Rochechouart, Baron de Barbozan
Died during the religious wars, near Parmiers

X de Rochechouart, Comte de Vivonne
Wounded while passing the Rhine in 1672

X de Rochechouart, Seigneur de Clermont
Captain of the light horse, he was killed at Maastricht in 1673

François de Rochechouart
Killed at the battle of Seneff, 1674

X de Rochechouart, Duc de Vivonne
General of the king's galleys, he defeated the Spanish fleet at Messina; during that battle he was wounded and then created Maréchal of France

Charles-François de Rochechouart, Comte de Limoges 
Fatally wounded at Ypres in 1678

Louis-Victor de Rochechouart, Duc de Mortemart 
Another well-titled man, Louis-Victor was also Duc de Vivonne, Prince de Tonnay-Charente, Viceroy of Sicily and Premier Gentilhomme of the King's Bedchamber. He was wounded at the siege of Lille in 1667 and then again (seriously) while crossing the Rhine in 1672.

X de Rochechouart-Jussac
Killed at the Battle of Fleurus, 1690

Charles de Rochechouart, Marquis de Montpipeau
Killed at Leuze, 1691, at age 30

Louis de Rochechouart, Duc de Mortemart
Was considerably wounded at the beginning of the Battle of Eckeren but persisted fighting 

François-Charles de Rochechouart, Comte de Rochechouart
Shot in the arm at the Battle of Guastalla in 1734

X de Rochechouart
Killed during a skirmish against a force of hussars at Eins, 1734

Charles-Auguste de Rochechouart, Duc de Rochechouart
Grandee of Spain and Knight of the Saint-Louis, he served Louis XV as Premier Gentilhomme of the Bedchamber. He received two wounds at Ettingen, 1743, which he eventually died from

Pierre-Paul de Rochechouart
Killed at the Battle of Plaisance, 1746

X de Rochechouart, Chevalier de Rochechouart
Colonel of the Anjou-regiment, wounded in action on 10 August 1746, near Tidon

X de Rochechouart, Chevalier de Rochechouart
Killed at the battle of Turin, 1706 - it is rather sad that even the book on the history of the Rochechouart (written by a Rochechouart) does not even record his name

undefined
Louis-Victor de Rochechouart






Thursday, 25 April 2024

Movie Review: Jeanne du Barry (2023)

Starting off a new round of movie reviews, I have chosen five factors to be considered: historical accuracy, costumes, casting, locations and attention to detail.

Historical accuracy 

The initial part of the movie correctly show the early years of Madame du Barry but towards the end of the movie, the producers seem to have taken active steps to imbue Madame du Barry's story with a more dignified ending.

For instance, in the movie, Jeanne is constantly at Louis XV's side while he is dying from smallpox - in reality, he was nursed by his daughters, not Jeanne. Once he officially renounces her in order to receive the sacraments, there is a dramatic scene in which she nearly leaves quietly in a carriage (as she actually did) but then bolts back over the courtyard, forces her way into the antechamber and is permitted by Louis Auguste, the dauphin, to say a last goodbye.

Throughout the movie, Louis Auguste (later Louis XVI) is shown to be the only one in the royal family who shows her any kindness. In reality, he had no regard for his father's mistress and absolutely ignored her. But at least he is present; both of his brothers and sisters are completely cut from the movie, even when all the royal children gather at their father's apartment throughout the movie. Instead, Louis is presented as the sole child of the next generation, thus cutting four children, three of whom would themselves become monarchs: the Comtes de Provence and d'Artois as well as Madame Clothilde. Marie Leszczynska, too, is mentioned but only as being "discreet" and then conveniently dying without appearing on screen.

The movie focuses on her life before and at court - the last shot of the main character shows her disconsolate in a barren cell at a nunnery. The 15 years she spent at Louveciennes are not included which is reasonable considering the otherwise overly long movie. As is typical for period dramas, the fate of the protagonist is explained by writing on the screen - unfortunately, it is not quite accurate.

For one, it is claimed that Marie Antoinette eventually turned from her bitterest enemy to a supporter. While Marie Antoinette did plead her case and eventually convinced Louis XVI to release Jeanne from the convent and let her live at Louveciennes, it is a massive stretch to imagine that the two women became friendly. In fact, they never saw each other again and certainly did not correspond. Marie's goodwill was a typical display of kindness and magnanimity from her side which was likely gratefully accepted by Jeanne.

Finally, the last words of Jeanne are recorded - or are they? The movie claims that her last words are the poetic "Please Monsieur, one more moment" followed by the even more serene "I have loved life too much to die in such a manner". While it is fairly accepted that she did plead for one more moment, the latter appear to be somewhat invented for the movie; sadly, the poor Jeanne was utterly terrified and refused to go quietly to her death. She (understandably) panicked while being transferred to the scaffold, crying out "You are going to hurt me!" - heartbreaking but not nearly as dignified as that last statement displayed on the screen.


And what of the court? A recurring theme is the truly bizarre way of leaving a room in a society where it was forbidden to turn one's back on the king. It is shown that people took tiny steps, scurrying backwards towards the door - while they did walk backwards, there is nothing to indicate that they scurried like cockroaches which seems to have been added for comedic effect.

However, the king's routine is briefly mentioned which is fairly accurate - council meetings, hunting, dinners etc.

But then there is the comment regarding Madame de Pompadour, Jeanne's predecessor. She is outright said to have created the Parc-aux-Cerfs to provide the king with women for her less pleasant duties as royal mistress. In fact, there is nothing to suggest that Madame de Pompadour did any such thing - on the contrary, every woman who emerged through the Parc-aux-Cerfs was a potential threat to her own position. Considering that that very threat is explicitly mentioned - even shown by the fact that Louis XV continues to sleep with other women in the movie - it is odd that the statement should be included at all.

Costumes

The costumes of the king's household are immaculate - particularly La Borde and the king's royal bodyguards. These rarely appear at all in movies about Versailles and if so, it is very briefly. Yet, this movie often put the king's household servants up front, particularly when the king is walking. He was always flanked by the royal bodyguards in their blue/red uniforms which is clearly represented.

Many of the costumes for the dauphin, dauphine and Louis XV are quite accurate - but then, something went wrong.


SNARK WEEK: Jeanne du Barry (2023) Makes Interesting Choices – Frock Flicks
Marie Antoinette and Louis XVI


While Mesdames - with the exception of Louise, who (for some reason) is dressed like a March-sister from Little Women - are typically dressed in the panniered rococo-gowns, their wigs are outrageous. Particularly the choice for the presentation of Madame du Barry is downright bizarre, especially because the women surrounding them are wearing period-accurate hair.

SNARK WEEK: Jeanne du Barry (2023) Makes Interesting Choices – Frock Flicks
A good example - notice the outrageous hair of the Mesdames to the left and the 
oddly Puritan ensemble of Madame Louise (brown dress)


Then there is the protagonist. Undoubtedly, her wardrobe has some accuracy to it - for instance, Madame du Barry was well-known to favour white gowns because the colour suited her particularly well. Stripes, too, were becoming increasingly popular. But then again, it seems like the same irrationality that seized the hairdresser of Mesdames also found Jeanne's wardrobe. Whether it is the modern wedding gown she wears for the feast upon Marie Antoinette's arrival or the gauzy, crinoline gown chosen for her mourning, it is just odd. 

SNARK WEEK: Jeanne du Barry (2023) Makes Interesting Choices – Frock Flicks
Another example of the sheer oddity of Mesdames costumes

Just like Mesdames, no one else is dressed in a similar fashion and it is only sporadically for the main character which would rule out the Reign-tendency to dress historical characters in modern couture. Perhaps this is due to the fact that Chanel was chosen as the sole partner for the movie?


Credit: Chanel (yes, this is an actual
still from the movie)


For those who appreciate the details in costuming, the pannier used by Madame du Barry is very clearly shown in all its glory. Also, the attention to the costumes of the king's household is praiseworthy. La Borde's uniform is an exact replica of the ones worn by the officers in the king's household. His military household, too, is pristine in its blue/red uniform complete with both swords and halberds.  

Casting

Maïwenn Besco succeeded in bringing the easy-going nature of Madame du Barry forth; her ready laughter and saucy side is both very well represented. However, from a purely external point of view, the casting choice is somewhat odd. Madame du Barry was praised for angelic softness in her features with her rounded cheeks and soft nose and chin. In contract, Maïwenn Besco has gorgeous cheekbones sharp enough to cut oneself on, an aquiline nose and narrow chin - quite the opposite. 

Likewise, Madame du Barry was notoriously blonde whereas the dark tresses of Besco has been preserved for the movie. So, while Mäiwenn Besco clearly understood the complexities of du Barry's character, her look simply does not resemble the real Jeanne.

From street seller to the royal fold: King Louis XV's mistress was the  ultimate social climber | Tatler
The real Jeanne du Barry


As can be seen, the rosy cheeks of Madame du Barry and those near-purple pale eyes are clearly on display. It does not help that the makeup chosen for Besco was often very heavy on the lips with focus on very dark red tones.


You are currently viewing Jeanne du Barry de Maïwenn : pourquoi le film est une déception
Maïwenn Besco



On the other hand, the choice of Pauline Pollmann for a teenaged Marie Antoinette is perfect. Pauline Pollman shared the archduchesses' golden locks, large blue eyes and soft lips. The makeup department certainly did everything to make Pollmann look the part - and for once, she actually looks like a teenager:

Film : Jeanne du Barry, avec Johnny Depp. De la réalisatrice Maïwenn - Page  3
Pauline Pollmann as Marie Antoinette


Proantic: Portrait Of The Queen Of Marie Antoinette Represented As Dau
Marie Antoinette as dauphine


Locations

While drones have clearly been used to give some beautiful shots of Versailles, the interior locations seem replicated in a studio. Only the Hall of Mirrors and the chapel appears to have been shot on location. For instance, a lot of the movie takes place in the king's private bedchamber but the room chosen for movie has nothing to do with the king's actual private bedchamber; its décor is completely off and even the windows' placement indicates that it is not the real deal.

The same can be said for the council chamber - in a scene in which Madame du Barry interrupts a council meeting, the room is fairly easy to examine from several perspectives. The room is clad in somewhat dark wooden panelling rather than the gloriously rococo council chamber of Versailles.

Even Madame du Barry's own apartment seems somewhat computer-reproduced. Her apartment was vast and luxuriously decorated but it is shown only briefly - only one room is shown in its full length - and even then, the attention seems to be deliberately drawn away from the room. For instance, when about to leave Versailles upon the death of Louis XV, the bedchamber of du Barry is almost entirely obscured by trunks and the camera focuses on her face and person. Overall, it gives the impression that the majority of the movie was not shot on location - perhaps they were not given permission?

It is, however, a nice touch that Marie Antoinette's arrival at court is observed from the birds'-eye-view of Madame du Barry's apartment - exactly where she would have seen her soon-to-be rival arrive.

Attention to detail

While the plot took some liberties with its accuracy, the producers did include some wonderful details. A personal favourite is the inclusion of the justaucorps bleu - these were the gentlemen who followed the king on his hunt by the king's explicit invitation. They were always 12 in number and wore a matching hunting suit of blue fabric. For a brief moment, when Louis XV (Johnny Depp) goes off hunting, a few gentlemen can be seen following him on horseback wearing the justaucorps. It is neither elaborated nor even noted in any particularity but is a treat nonetheless.

Another treat was the king's levée - it is seen in all its glory, even including the varying entrées - stages by which certain courtiers could access the king's chamber - and the sight of courtiers waiting in the king's antechamber if they did not have the entrées. 

Wednesday, 13 March 2024

The Tragic Decline of the Comte de La Vauguyon

On 29 November 1693, Louis XIV was informed of the tragic suicide of one of his courtiers: the Comte de La Vauguyon. The incident was related in a rather casual manner by the Duc de Saint-Simon in his memoirs. However, Saint-Simon made it clear that the gunshots in his throat was of "less surprise than interest" due to the Comte's obviously declining mental health.


For years, André de Béthoulat, Comte de La Vauguyon had suffered a steady decline. Being unfortunately poor in finances, he possessed several traits necessary to make a successful career at court. Gallantry (highly prized by Louis XIV himself) was one, a good singing voice and the good fortune of enjoying the favours of Madame de Beauvais. She was the one who had allegedly "initiated" Louis XIV into life's more sensual pleasures for which she was generally respected and treated remarkably well by the king.

Saint-Simon attributed the seemingly good career of La Vauguyon to his mistress' favour with the king; the duke never seems to have considered that perhaps the king also liked La Vauguyon for his own sake. Either way, on the outside, La Vauguyon was doing quite well for himself at court. After several stints abroad as ambassador (a post which in itself required a certain degree of trust from the king) he was made councillor of state before finally being awarded the knighthood.

Yet, then followed a period of nothing - no appointments, no favours, no positions. This left him in a dire financial situation which Saint-Simon attributed to his increasingly odd behaviour. In other words, the duke argued that La Vauguyon's failing fortunes had literally made him lose his mind.



Thanks to Saint-Simon, we know of some of the odd incidents leading up to the tragic conclusion in 1693. La Vauguyon seems to have been overcome by episodes of extreme and unprovoked anger. One episode was said to have occurred at the house of Madame Pelot, the wife of the President of the Rouen Parliament. The party had been playing in the gambling room when the hostess gently teased him about the game. He allegedly waited until the remaining company had left before attacking poor Madame Pelot, pinning her against the wall and threatening to bash her skull in. According to Saint-Simon, she had only mentioned it after his death but it had been noticed that after that evening, she was never alone with him again. However, it seems remarkable that she would never say anything to anyone - after all, she had been attacked in her own home.


Another incidence of such unprovoked rancor occured at Fontainebleau in October 1691 when he passed the Prince de Courtenay, a gentleman with whom he had never had an issue before. Yet on that day, La Vauguyon suddenly drew his sword in such a threatening manner that Courtenay was obliged to do the same. Drawing one's weapon within the king's residence was a massive mistake - it could easily result in either exile or downright imprisonment. Passers-by managed to prevent further escalation but not before La Vauguyon turned on his heel and bolted away. 

He headed straight for the king's apartment where he forced his way past the usher who desperately tried keeping him away. Finally, he literally broke into the king's private chamber where the king - somewhat startled, one might imagine - demanded to know what was happening. Thus, La Vauguyon threw himself to the ground and insisted that M. de Courtenay had grievously insulted him and he had therefore had no choice but to draw his weapon. Understandably, Courtenay claimed the same and both were sent to the Bastille for a short while. The king was greatly disturbed by the incident and even ordered an investigation into the matter. It was up to the Prévôt d'Hôtel to ensure the safety of the court - consequently, he was put in charge. The feuding pair was released in July 1692.


Having been granted permission to return to court, La Vauguyon was considered with a wary eye by his fellow courtiers. If they were hoping for another bizarre incident, they were soon satisfied. Being free from the Bastille, La Vauguyon soon convinced himself that he had somehow angered the king beyond reason. In October 1692 (a year after his would-be duel) he happened to pass by a servant of the Prince de Condé who was walking the prince's horse. Having ascertained whom the horse belonged to, La Vauguyon claimed that the prince would not object to his lending it before jumping onto its back and riding off - poor servant, he must have been both utterly confused and somewhat fearful of his employer's reaction.

Where was La Vauguyon going? He headed straight for Paris, more precisely the Bastille. Having convinced himself of the king's ire, he had apparently decided to hand himself in. Consequently, he approached the governor of the prison and demanded to be locked away as he expected the king's anger to conduct him there anyhow. Taken aback, the governor checked his papers and found no order for the confinement of La Vauguyon and declined to imprison him. It took a remarkable effort on the governor's behalf to make La Vauguyon leave and they agreed initially that La Vauguyon would retire to his house while the governor investigated. Thus, sending a quick messenger to Versailles, the king confirmed that no arrest had been ordered and the "house arrest" was lifted.



Meanwhile, the king continued to allow La Vauguyon at court. Clearly, the man was suffering from some sort of mental disorder which unfortunately rendered him quite unpredictable. Upon the death of his wife, he appeared to go completely over the edge. Insisting on traveling with loaded pistols - not for safety, mind you - he frequently drew them and aimed at his own servants before calmly putting them away again.


By this point, his finances were said to be entirely dreadful. Saint-Simon, for one, was sure that he would never have survived without the assistance of both M. de Beauvais (Madame de Beauvais' son) and the king's own charity. While the king continued to treat him with kindness, he also withheld any means of improving La Vauguyon's situation. According to the Marquis de Sourches, he had requested to be sent as ambassador to Sweden which would provide him with both a fixed wage and honorable employment. However, the king refused which prompted La Vauguyon to lament that he was being sabotaged - not by the king, but by others who rendered him "bad service", i.e. bad-mouthing him to the king.


Interestingly, these incidents are not the first oddities concerning the Comte. Years earlier, the Marquis de Sourches casually remarked that La Vauguyon was being recalled from his position as ambassador to Vienna due to "great inconveniences". The wording is tantalizingly vague. Were these inconveniences financial in nature? Perhaps La Vauguyon's finances were already so disturbed as to prevent him doing his job properly. However, it is worth considering whether La Vauguyon was already exhibiting odd behavior. Obviously, he was not already plagued by the outbursts of his later years, as this would undoubtedly have been reported elsewhere. 


The end was the tragic suicide of La Vauguyon in November 1693. It is interesting to speculate what exactly led him to such a desperate act?


He might have been utterly depressed at his situation - penniless with no prospects of gaining employment or receiving aid from the king. Given that his behaviour seem to have gotten worse after the death of his wife, it is not unlikely that her loss only furthered his spiral into depression.

Desparation and frustration could also explain the odd outbursts of violence but there is another element which warrants consideration: early dementia.

La Vauguyon was 63 when he committed suicide. Every odd incident had occurred within a few years previously which indicates that he had not always been prone to the behaviour he was suddenly showcasing. Changed personality, confusion, mood changes, depression - all are symptoms of early dementia. The phrasing of the Marquis de Dangeau is worth noticing. When La Vauguyon was informed that he would, in fact, not be going to Sweden, he "fell into such a fit of despair, that he became rather deranged". The following day, Dangeau reported that he had "recovered his senses". The choice of words could indicate that La Vauguyon was experiencing an episode of some king. 

Furthermore, Louis XIV was notoriously prickly when it came to his honour. The fact that he never considered La Vauguyon's odd outbursts - even when directed at the king's behaviour - to be an affront could indicate that the king saw fit to treat La Vauguyon with more kindness and consideration than usual.


Whether or not La Vauguyon suffered from dementia or succumbed to depression, it is difficult not to sympathise with him. Either way, he was clearly suffering from a horrible mental health crisis - potentially worsened by the pressure of his awful financial situation - which eventually cost him his life.

Monday, 11 March 2024

The Only Protestant Lord in France: The Persecution of the Duc de La Force

Jacques Nompar de Caumont, Duc de La Force, was said to be "le seul grand seigneur huguenot" - the only great, Huguenot lord in France. As a duke and peer, Jacques was definitely a grand lord - he was also a Protestant.

Protestantism had not entirely passed by France which otherwise remained staunchly catholic. Few of the aristocrats had adopted the new religion but they were far outnumbered. Until the 1680's this divergence was treated rather as the proverbial elephant in the room - not to be acknowledged. However, when Louis XIV revoked the Edict of Nantes in October 1685 spelled disaster for Protestants within France.

Established as so-called "irrevocable law" (ironic, considering that it not even last a century), the Edict of Nantes had established fundamental rights for Protestants within France. Catholicism was acknowledged as the state religion but Protestants were ensured their freedom of religion. Yet, with the stroke of a pen, Louis XIV made Protestantism illegal - those practicing were given a dire ultimatum: convert to Catholicism or leave France (and everything you have). 


Whereas thousands of commoners found themselves in a downright deadly situation - with evidence of some being tortured into conversion or facing starvation as a result of having to abandon every earthly belonging - the courtiers were not in direct peril.

Jacques Nompar, for one, was somewhat protected by his status as a duke and peer - or so he might have thought. Attempts were made to make Jacques willingly convert - civilised conversation, gentle prodding etc. etc. However, two factors made the conversion almost impossible. For one, Jacques Nompar does not appear to have had any particular, personal interest in religion. While there is little doubt that he did believe in god, the finer mechanisms of Protestantism versus Catholicism were far more open to discussion than for most of his contemporaries. One of those contemporaries also makes up the second factor. His second wife (and mother of his sons) was an intensely Protestant woman whose devotion to her faith made even the king's attempts to convert her utterly useless. The fact that the two enjoyed a close relationship certainly heightened the influence her conviction had on her more pliable husband.

Fanatical, Jacques certain was not, yet his refusal to simply obey and convert was a sore spot for the king. Having attempted the gentle approach, the king had enough of his "obstinacy" and decided that if the duke could not be persuaded, he could be forced.


On 22 April 1685 (mind you, before the official revocation of the Edict of Nantes), the Duc de La Force was arrested by the king's police while staying in Paris. As befit his rank, he was escorted to the Bastille. There, he was subjected to immense pressure with the background of the royal fortress to remind him of his position. To convince him of the errors of his ways, the king appointed M. Bordes who was in for a long and tiring mental battle. In the end, the duke remained steadfast - he would not convert.


Meanwhile, if the duke was determined not to convert, the king was determined not to release him until he did. Thus, two years later, Jacques Nompar was still imprisoned. He had been placed under the care of the Duc de Duras who could eventually report to the king that his charge was seriously ill. Whether the illness was a matter of chance or the result of misuse is not known. Realising that he might die in prison, Jacques Nompar gave the king the conversion he wanted - on paper, at least.

For his compliance, he was released into the care of his wife. She, too, was a staunch Protestant, but had remained out of prison although the king had tried to force her into a conversion, too. Suzanne de Béringhen (as was her name) was described as being even more determined in her faith than her husband and she undoubtedly supported his return to Protestantism. It says something of her faith that her husband was considered a reasonable target for "persuasion" whereas she was "a lost cause".

Having been nursed back to health, it soon became clear that Jacques Nompar had little intention to actually become a proper Catholic. Angry at the seeming turnabout, the king promptly refused to grand Jacques Nompar the prestigious Order of St. Michel. According to Dangeau, the king even deigned to have private discussions with the duke on the importance of his converting. When that did not have the desired effect, Jacques was sent to his estates to mull things over in 1686. However, if the king had thought that some good old-fashioned public snubbing would bring the duke to heel, he was wrong. Jacques Nompar continued his insistence of religious freedom, much to the annoyance of the king. Perhaps the irritation was made even worse by the fact that Jacques continuously allowed the king's preachers to assume that they had won.

In May 1686, the Mercure Gallante reported that the Duc de La Force had finally been convinced of the "errors of Protestantism" and had therefore become a good Catholic. It did not even last a year before it became clear that that was definitely not the case. Still, the same publication gleefully reported on the successful conversion of his sons not long after. 


Eventually, Louis XIV could not abide the open defiance of an obviously Protestant duke at his own court. It was honestly getting embarrassing considering the harsh measures taken everywhere else; the duke's refusal could potentially be seen as disobedience which in itself would be damaging to the king's power. The duke himself did nothing to hide his continued adherence to Protestantism. His private château left little doubt that its lord was not a Catholic. Even worse, from the king's point of view, he allowed his household servants to also continue in their Protestantism. In a particularly petty move, three servants were seized from his estate and imprisoned.

Meanwhile, his papers were seized and his private testament was discovered which showed that he still considered himself a Protestant. If the king ever needed concrete proof that the abjuration had been false, he had it now. There was only one thing to do: sent him back to the Bastille.


So, on 14 July 1689, Jacques Nompar was once again escorted back to the Bastille. It was whispered that his arrest was the result of an alleged conspiracy with the British. Conveniently, that would serve to draw a link between the French rival and this obstinate duke, thus villainising both. The Duchesse did not escape notice either. She remained a thorn in the eye of the king - it was one thing to imprison an obstinate nobleman but Louis XIV had always been raised to be the very picture of gallantry. It did not sit right with him to force the Duchesse into the Bastille as well - consequently, she remained under house arrest, far from her husband. House arrest turned into downright prisons where she was kept as isolated as possible.


The duke had three sons and four daughters - before escorting Jacques to his prison, the king made a show of removing his children. On the orders of the king, the daughters were quickly dispatched to convents where they would be converted; meanwhile, the sons quickly bowed to the pressure and lack of any type of support. They would not be handed back to their parents afterwards but would be the charges of their god-mother, the Duchesse de Saint-Simon. One of the girls, Marie-Anne-Louise, was rewarded with a position in the household of the dauphine and a marriage. Sadly, she would widowed after just two years and would later be exiled from court for improper conduct - the whispers of an illegitimate child with none less than the Grand Dauphin could explain the reason. 

Another, Jeanne, eagerly took to convincing the court that she had indeed converted and was promptly married off advantageously to the marquis de Courtomer. The two others remained at the convent as nuns.

It must have been heartbreaking, particularly for the Duchesse de La Force, to have her children forcibly removed and then bullied into converting to a religion she herself had always resisted. Yet, there was nothing to be done.


The entire de La Force-family soon came under fire, although not nearly as intensely as the head of their house. Many fled to England or the Netherlands where the men joined the army or simply blended into the aristocracy. For one, Pierre Nompar de Caumont married the daughter of another Huguenot who happened to serve as the Prince of Wales' doctor.


What of Jacques Nompar? He remained imprisoned until 29 April 1691 before being transferred to a monastery. It was said that he - having always been less fiercely religious than his wife - had actually wanted to convert this time. Perhaps the king thought the change of scenery would evoke the same change of heart as it had for his daughters? If so, the king was mistaken. Whatever change might have happened in the monastery, once he was permitted back to his estates, his wife was released as well - and she quickly undid the persuasive techniques of the monks. The king was furious with the Duchesse; in his mind, she was undoing everything he had spent years accomplishing. He even went so far as to order her to relocate as she was "inspiring her husband with sentiments contrary to the good faith".

Obeying, the Duchesse retired - for a while. Then she returned to her husband which led the king to continue his spying on the couple, irate that the duke listened more to his wife than his king. He even dispatched both policemen and M. Bordes to counteract the influence of the Duchesse. 


Henri Jacques - the heir who 
turned Catholic with a vengeance


By the time he was 67, Jacques' health was seriously declining. It soon became clear that he was dying. Realising that they had to move quickly to ensure his soul for the Catholic faith, he was continuously pressed to reconsider before it was too late. The Duchesse was even forcibly kept from his apartment to prevent any "relapse". Yet, Jacques Nompar refused - proving that his initial abjuration had been a sham. He would die as he had lived - as a Protestant. And so he did, expiring on 19 April 1699. 

Louis XIV was allegedly told that he died a good Catholic although he never did make a genuine abjuration. 


Upon his death, the Duchesse de La Force finally obtained permission to leave France for England where she was received with sympathy. She was allegedly presented with the age-old dilemma: convert or go into exile. She would die in England at 81, having survived Louis XIV by 16 years and his attempts at forcible conversion even longer. Ironically, one of her own sons - the heir, Henri Jacques - became intensely Catholic (unfortunately of the bigoted kind) who would forcibly convert those living on his estates.